2024中的第二篇,给各位同志分享一下时间线以供参考 Submission received 30 Apr 2024 Submission is under technical check 30 Apr 2024 Amendment requested 14 May 2024 Amendment received 14 May 2024 Submission passed technical check 25 May 2024 Ready for editorial assignment 25 May 2024 Editor assigned 25 May 2024 Submission under peer review 28 May 2024 Revision requested 28 Jun 2024 Revision received 02 Jul 2024 Submission accepted 11 Jul 2024
投了一篇meta Submission received 07 Mar 2024 Submission passed technical check 07 Mar 2024 Editor assigned 13 Mar 2024 Submission under peer review 13 Mar 2024 Revision received 27 May 2024 Submission accepted 27 Jun 2024 Submission is in publishing and rights 27 Jun 2024 优点:英国老牌杂志,不算水刊,有一定认可度,编辑也比较友好,审稿人也比较负责,提的意见还算中肯,对meta友好。 缺点:BMC出了名的比较墨迹,编辑回邮件有的时候间隔时间很长。
2024年投的第三篇,前两篇基本都是三个月左右接受,第三篇龟速。4.22投,5.10开始外审,官网显示5.17收到审稿人报告,但是一直还是peer review的状态。给编辑发了好几封邮件均石沉大海。有点无语!
3
2024中的第二篇,给各位同志分享一下时间线以供参考
Submission received 30 Apr 2024
Submission is under technical check 30 Apr 2024
Amendment requested 14 May 2024
Amendment received 14 May 2024
Submission passed technical check 25 May 2024
Ready for editorial assignment 25 May 2024
Editor assigned 25 May 2024
Submission under peer review 28 May 2024
Revision requested 28 Jun 2024
Revision received 02 Jul 2024
Submission accepted 11 Jul 2024
19
投了一篇meta
Submission received 07 Mar 2024
Submission passed technical check 07 Mar 2024
Editor assigned 13 Mar 2024
Submission under peer review 13 Mar 2024
Revision received 27 May 2024
Submission accepted 27 Jun 2024
Submission is in publishing and rights 27 Jun 2024
优点:英国老牌杂志,不算水刊,有一定认可度,编辑也比较友好,审稿人也比较负责,提的意见还算中肯,对meta友好。
缺点:BMC出了名的比较墨迹,编辑回邮件有的时候间隔时间很长。
24
审稿周期长,半年多才一审回来。
0
审稿速度:3.0 | 投稿命中率:75.0
偏重的研究方向:临床研究
经验分享:投稿到接收不到4个月,挺顺利,一审小修,二审后直接接收!
56
投稿需要 provide a separate document detailing the trial protocol in the English language only? 这个怎么写,感觉要写好多
53
审稿速度:6.0
经验分享:现在审稿很墨迹,非常墨迹,得写几次催稿信。
42
偏重的研究方向:临床麻醉
经验分享:外审结束了,waiting for decision已经两周了。写信也不回,啥情况?
49
审稿速度:6.0 | 投稿命中率:50.0
经验分享:审稿特别慢,我的一篇文章被审了4个月,中间还替换了审稿人,不建议投,浪费时间!
61
啊无语了,1月16投稿的,1月23 Peer review,一直到现在仍自是peer review。。。。。。发邮件催了2次,每次回复都是没有找到负责的审稿人,,,,,,,,,,想哭,5个月了。。。。。
68